I caught Mr. Pinchy a few months ago for the first time. But unfortunately he didn’t drop the Magical Crawdad pet for me. Instead I got Mr. Pinchy’s Gift (Healing and Mana Potions), and Furious Mr. Pinchy, twice.
But last Friday luck was with me as I was fishing in Skettis. I caught Mr. Pinchy again. You get three wishes from Mr. Pinchy. But they are random, you dont pick them and there is a 48 hour cooldown until you can “wish” again. Friday I got the potions again. Sunday, Furious Mr. Pinchy. But today the Magical Crawdad Box dropped. It’s about time!